It seems Edward Caban’s naming to the position of police commissioner was in the cards since the sudden resignation of Keechant Sewell last month.

“I remember my conversation with [Sewell] and stating, ‘I’m looking toward [Caban] to be the next commissioner.’ And she simply said, “He’s ready,” Mayor Eric Adams said Monday morning at a press conference.

Unlike his previous position as deputy commissioner, Caban will be the face of public safety in the city.

“This is a hard job, a difficult job. You know, today you’re applauded. The love affair only lasts a few days,” Adams said on Monday before introducing Caban.

What You Need To Know

  • Caban will have to navigate the politics of City Hall

  • Adams already has two officials who weigh in on public safety, including First Deputy Mayor Phil Banks and top aide Tim Pearson

  • Caban, unlike Sewell, comes from the NYPD and has been working alongside the administration as the deputy commissioner for over a year

The 32-year veteran will now be tasked with taking over a department that has been somewhat successful recently at driving down shootings and homicides.

On Monday, Caban was sworn in at the Bronx precinct where he started his career.

“Normally police commissioners are sworn in at City Hall. By [Caban] being sworn in front of the 40th precinct, he’s sending a direct message: I remember where I came from. I’m concerned about what happens on the street, and I’m supporting the men and women on patrol,” Wilbur Chapman, former chief of patrol, said.

Caban’s biggest challenge is going to be dealing with City Hall.

The new commissioner will be reporting to Adams directly. However, other people who weigh in on public safety include First Deputy Mayor Phil Banks and former cop and top aide Tim Pearson.

“When you reach that level of management in the police department, you have your own philosophy on how to police. And truly the manner of how to police should be determined by the police commissioner through the mayor saying, ‘I have faith in you and your ability to do the job,’ and allowing them to be independent in their operation,” Chapman said.

Both Banks and Pearson were in attendance at Monday’s announcement, with Banks kicking off the event.

“Good morning, good morning and welcome all,” Banks said as he opened up the announcement on Monday morning.

How Caban deals with the mayor’s management system could play a crucial role in his success. Different from Sewell, Caban has decades of experience as a New York City police officer.

“He and Banks, if they are philosophically in tune, then there won’t be an issue. But when there is a difference of opinion, we will be able to monitor how much independence Caban is allowed and how much direction he takes from Banks,” Chapman said.

It’s unclear how many other candidates were considered for the role of police commissioner and whether Adams prioritized naming another woman.